All work

Case study 3 of 3 · Ecommerce · Web · 4 min read

Multi-store Click & Collect

Customers could only collect from one store. When a new store opened, I redesigned the journey so people could choose where to collect from, without messing up their basket. The product page project was about how you can get an item. This one was about where.

The final product page, showing stock and aisle at the chosen store
The final product page, with your chosen store

The impact

~180Orders in the new store's first month
~£34kIn sales that month, in a quiet month for trade
75%Of those customers had never used Click & Collect before

Summary

RoleIn-house product designer
Timeline2026 · 3 months
ToolsFigma, GA4, Clarity
PlatformAdobe Commerce

ProblemClick & Collect only worked for one store, with no way to choose.

Key decisionAsk people to choose a store or postcode once, early, and carry it through the whole site.

OutcomeThe new store took ~180 orders in its first month, mostly from people new to Click & Collect.

A second store opened

At the builders' merchant where I worked, Click & Collect was doing well: over £1.5m in sales in 2025, with orders more than doubling. But you could only collect from the main store, and the whole site was built around that.

When a new store opened in 2026, customers started asking to collect from there. I had about three months as the in-house designer, with our agency's designers advising when needed.

Why one store wasn't enough

  • You couldn't choose a store. Press Collect and it went in your basket for the main store.
  • Stock didn't follow you. You had to check stock again on every product page.
  • No postcode until checkout, so people could fill a basket with heavy stuff and then find out we couldn't deliver to them.

And stock is different in every store, so switching store could mean half your basket isn't available.

Before: three separate journeys, none of them connected

What customers needed

I used feedback forms, customer and stakeholder interviews, and analytics (GA4 and Clarity). Different customers wanted different things:

  • Click & Collect customers want to know what's available, fast.
  • In-store customers want to know what we've got and where it is.
  • Delivery customers need to know we can deliver before they fill a basket.

One customer summed it up: "How much is it, where is it, and how can I get it."

01The stock checker was liked but hidden

People who found it liked it, but most people didn't, and opening it on every page was a pain.

02Competitors ask up front

Screwfix, Toolstation and Travis Perkins all ask you to choose a store or area first.

Asking for a store early

The big decision was asking people to choose a store or postcode up front. It adds a step, which I wasn't keen on. But your store changes everything you see: stock, and whether you can collect at all.

We looked at two other options:

  • A separate store page. Too many clicks just to get back to shopping.
  • Only asking at checkout. That would mean people still didn't know what was available at the start, and with different stock in every store, that was the whole problem with the old site.

So we ask once, early, in a small pop-up, and it sticks across the product page, basket and checkout. You can be asked at different points depending on what you're doing (pressing Collect, pressing Deliver, checking stock, or changing store from the top bar), but they all look and work the same, so it feels like one thing.

If you change store, it warns you what that means for your basket before you switch.

After: choose a store or postcode once, and it's applied everywhere

The basket is split into Collect and Deliver. Items can move between them, and if you want more than a store has, it tells you exactly how many are available.

The final designs

The same pop-up in four places: Collect, In-store stock, Set store and Delivery
The old stock pop-up against the new one, with stock levels, aisle and your selected store
The split cart: items that can't be collected are flagged, with one-tap fixes like delivering them instead

Before I left, I pulled the colours and components from these projects into a starter design system, so the next designer and the developers could reuse them.

The start of a design system I built in Figma: colours, buttons, alerts, inputs and the store card

Try a working version

A simplified version of the product page with made-up stock levels, so you can try it yourself:

  1. No store is set yet, like a first visit. Tap Choose store, or the bar at the top, to pick one.
  2. Tap Check stock in all stores to compare stores.
  3. Tap Collect to reserve it at a store, or Deliver to enter a postcode.
  4. Choose Acton, then switch to the cement mixer. It's out of stock there, so Collect becomes Change store to collect.

It's built with HTML, CSS and JavaScript, matching the real design.

What testing changed

I tested with 5 trade customers and some staff. A stakeholder wanted a greyed-out Collect button with a small link underneath. I pushed for one clear button instead, but made it white so it didn't compete with Deliver.

Change store to collect

Tried
One white button, so it didn't compete with Deliver.
Learned
People hovered over it and hesitated. I'd argued for white on principle, and testing showed me I was wrong.
Changed
Made it the main blue button. On the retest, nobody hesitated.

The desktop store picker

Tried
A panel sliding in from the side. On mobile it filled the screen, so nobody missed it.
Learned
On desktop people missed it, and some didn't realise they had to pick a store.
Changed
Moved it to the middle of the screen, like the delivery one, and the problem went away.
BeforeFirst version: a white Change store to collect button
AfterFinal version: a primary blue Change store to collect button
Before: a white button people hesitated over. After: primary blue, and the hesitation went

Results

~180

Orders in the new store's first month

Around £34,000, in a quiet month for trade

75%

Of those customers were new to it

It opened Click & Collect up to new people nearby

Before this, the website could only take Click & Collect orders for the main store, so none of these orders could have been placed online.

Once you choose a store, every product page shows its stock and aisle without opening anything, and new stores can be switched on without a rebuild.

Reviews have stayed very positive since launch.

“Used the Acton store for click and collect. Very easy you click on the text once you have parked and they bring it out to you.”
Trustpilot review, September 2026

What I'd do next time

The basket warning says something might change, but not what. I'd make it specific, like "2 items aren't available at this store", so people know before they switch.

Want to hear more?

There's more I can share about this project, like how the split basket and store choice work together. I'm happy to talk it through.